In the spirit of backlog* (which is the real theme of my blog), I've been meaning to write about a couple of concerns I had after reading Edward Castranova and Matthew Falk's article in the October issue of Games and Culture entitled Virtual Worlds: Petri Dishes, Rat Mazes, and Supercolliders. Now let me start by saying that Professor Castranova has the unenviable task of representing a relatively controversial research ideology within the context of the emerging field of virtual worlds research. There are a lot of methodologically qualitative/ epistemologically constructivist researchers in this field, and Castranova does generally quantitative work operating from a more or less Post-Positivist perspective. For the non-researchers among you, this means that he uses numbers a lot and that (as near as I can figure) he proceeds from an assumption that truth claims can be proven through measurement provided the tools are good enough.
Motivational Poster borrowed from xdr.com - In case you didn't notice I'm a big fan of these posters. This one has only a tenuous connection to this blog post.
Click to read more ...